Skip to Content
Multigenerational family talking on couch representing that different stages require different insurance policy types.
Policy Types

Compare and contrast: Indexed universal life vs. whole life insurance

When you buy permanent* life insurance, you have a few options. Two popular choices are whole life insurance and indexed universal life (IUL).

Each type has unique features, and understanding the differences can help you choose what may be best for you and your family.

How they're the same

To compare and contrast, get familiar with some of the shared features available from both types of policies. Because they are permanent life insurance contracts, whole life and IUL both offer the potential for building cash values and securing lifelong coverage.

Potential cash value: Cash value can accumulate and grow tax-deferred inside of your policy. You might use those funds for a variety of goals later, including supplemental retirement income, education funding or to help pay the ongoing expenses in your policy. This can be accomplished through policy loans or withdrawals. However, it's important to note that outstanding policy loans accrue interest and reduce cash value and the death benefit.

Permanent coverage: As long as you continue to pay your required premiums on time, your policy remains in force. Coverage can last for the rest of your life - regardless of how long you live. As a result, you can ensure that heirs receive a death benefit to help with living expenses or liquidity needs.

How they're different

While whole life and IUL share several similarities, premium payments and cash values work differently.

Premium payments

Premiums are typically monthly or annual payments you make to your insurance company. Your preference on how to handle premiums may help you decide which type of policy is best for you.

Whole life: With whole life policies, you receive a premium schedule at the time you establish coverage. As long as you pay those premiums on time, your coverage is guaranteed to stay in force, and your cash value will grow as illustrated. But for the same face value, whole life premiums are typically higher than IUL premiums at the beginning of your policy.

IUL premiums: IUL premiums are flexible. You can even skip premiums temporarily if you have sufficient cash value in your policy. However, if you pay too little into the policy or your cash value dwindles, you may need to pay higher premiums in later years to keep up with the costs of insurance.

Cash values

Although whole life and IUL policies can potentially provide cash values, those balances grow in different ways.

Whole life: Your cash value growth is guaranteed in a whole life policy. You know exactly how much you'll have available at any given time, assuming you make the scheduled premium payments. That's helpful for those who plan to use cash value for critical goals like a specific retirement date or a child's first year in college.

  • Dividends: Dividend-paying policies may provide additional value, but dividends are never guaranteed, and some policies don't offer dividends. If your policy receives dividends, you can typically use those funds to raise your death benefit, receive cash, reduce your premium payments and more.
  • IUL accumulation: The cash value growth in an IUL policy is subject to caps and floors and is based on the performance of a specified market index, such as the S&P 500. With good results, it may be possible to accumulate a significant amount of cash value or stop paying premiums for a period of time. However, if your cash value fails to grow, you may need to pay higher premiums to keep the policy in force.
  • Interest crediting: Policies may offer different options for growing your cash value, so the crediting rate depends on what you choose and how those options perform. A fixed segment earns interest at a specified rate, which may change over time with economic conditions. An indexed segment is linked to the performance of a market index, typically subject to both caps and floors.

Different strategies for different needs

Neither type of policy is necessarily better than the other - it all comes down to your goals and strategy.

Whole life policies may appeal to you if you prefer predictability. You know exactly how much you'll need to pay every year, and you can see how much cash value to expect in any given year.

IUL may be attractive if you need flexibility and you can afford the risk of having to pay more to keep the policy in force due to poor cash value growth.

When assessing life insurance needs, evaluate your long-term goals, your current and future expenses, and your desire for security. Discuss your goals with your agent, and choose the policy that works best for you.


*As long as required premium payments are timely made. Indexed Universal Life is not a security investment and is not an investment in the market.

All payments and all guarantees are subject to the claims paying ability of the insurer.

 

WEB.1225846.05.19

Arrows linking indicating relationship

Related Articles

Family spending quality time together.

Life insurance riders: Taking advantage of policy benefits in your life insurance policy

Learn more
Millennial woman browsing her smartphone on the steps of a building.

How millennials can benefit from paying whole life insurance rates

Learn more
Woman sitting in a wheelchair looking out the window while drinking coffee.

Understanding how disability insurance works

Learn more

All Learning Center articles are general summaries that can be used when considering your financial future at various life stages. The information presented is for educational purposes and is meant to supplement other information specific to your situation. It is not intended as investment advice and does not necessarily represent the opinion of Protective Life or its subsidiaries.

Learning Center articles may describe services and financial products not offered by Protective Life or its subsidiaries. Descriptions of financial products contained in Learning Center articles are not intended to represent those offered by Protective Life or its subsidiaries.

Neither Protective Life nor its representatives offer legal or tax advice. We encourage you to consult with your financial adviser and legal or tax adviser regarding your individual situations before making investment, social security, retirement planning, and tax-related decisions. For information about Protective Life and its products and services, visit www.protective.com.

Companies and organizations linked from Learning Center articles have no affiliation with Protective Life or its subsidiaries.